First Comes Love and Second Chance by Katie Kacvinsky Book Review

First Comes LoveIn honor of the paperback release of First Comes Love (out today!) I have a review of the book and the sequel Second Chance. First Comes Love came out a year ago with a very different smoldering-looking cover. The cover re-design sells a whole new image that I personally think match the tone of the story very well. Making up for lost time, I read the first two books in the series back to back.

First Comes Love is the story of Dylan and Gray, opposites in every way. Gray is drifting after suffering a loss; he’s depressed and lost focus, even giving up his college baseball scholarship. Dylan is a free spirit who loves to travel and live life to the fullest. She does not want to get tied down and is just into having experiences. Gray gets sucked into the bright light that is Dylan and against the odds the pair fall in love. But are they just too different to go the distance?

This is Katie Kacvinsky’s first contemporary series- she also writes the dystopian Awaken series. I think this is a seamless transition for Kacvinsky and I like that she wrote a New Adult book without even knowing it was a thing. After high school, life is not always easy for everyone with the perfect college and life, and this book addresses the messiness of it all.

I wanted Dylan to save Gray from his funk, and for Gray to help Dylan to settle down, but in this book there’s no easy answers or tidy ending. The way the two see each other kind of reminded me of Rainbow Rowell’s Eleanor & Park. Gray is drawn to Dylan, but also a little embarrassed of her too. She marches to the beat of her own drummer with ill-fitting mismatched clothes, messy hair and impulsive behavior.

We get inside both Dylan and Gray’s heads with alternating POV. Gray’s character is a little easier to warm up to than Dylan’s MPDG type. Still, I kind of loved that the two got together- they balance each other out. Writing slow-burn romance is Kacvinsky’s forte and that’s my favorite kind to read. There’s emotion and romance along with some light, heart-warming moments.

The summer in Arizona setting is a nice backdrop to the story, and Kacvinsky makes you feel like you are there with Gray and Dylan on their hikes and adventures. They also take a little road trip to Los Angeles and that just sets a vacation like mood.Second Chance

First Comes Love was written as a standalone, but Kacvinsky decided to extend the book to a trilogy. She self-published book two Second Chance. After reading First Comes Love, I felt satisfied by the ending as is, but was attached to the characters and glad to see Gray and Dylan’s story continue.

In Second Chance, there’s been a little distance between Gray and Dylan. Dylan is traveling around the world and doing her thing, while Gray is trying to go back to normal and reconnect with his college baseball goals. Where do the two fit in each other’s lives?

I like the angst and the opposites attract story- the two have chemistry, but they are such different people. I root for this pair and hope they make it work. In this book, there’s a new setting and new characters and stumbling blocks in the way of the couple’s HEA. Both Gray and Dylan still have some growing up to do and need to figure out what they want and if compromises can be made.

There’s one song Gray mentions listening to in the book (Missed the Boat by Modest Mouse) that kind of sums up the mood:

The laid back pace, setting and romance in this series makes for an ideal summer read to tuck in your beach bag. Dylan and Gray’s love story will leave you eager for the next book. (Write faster, Katie!)

I had the chance to interview Katie Kacvinsky recently about all her books, and you can check it out here and also enter the giveaway for your chance to win First Comes Love and Second Chance. I’m jealous of whoever wins! I borrowed First Comes Love from the library and bought a kindle edition of Second Chance but think I’ll have to pick up the paperbacks for my own library.

Find out more about the series here:

Goodreads | Amazon | Author’s website


10 thoughts on “First Comes Love and Second Chance by Katie Kacvinsky Book Review

  1. VeganYANerds says:

    I did not recognise the book at first, what a change in looks! But I like it, too. And it’s great that the author was able to publish the sequel

    That MM song reminds me of an episode of Scrubs, it adds great atmosphere to a scene.

    1. Lucy says:

      The cover vibe is totally different, isn’t it? I saw the paperback in the bookstore today and it’s so pretty and bright green.

      The song was in Scrubs? Interesting!

  2. Elin says:

    This book looks so beautiful:) Never heard of the book before.

  3. Sunny says:

    I’ve never heard of these, but they sound great! I love everything you mentioned between them and the fact that it’s alternating POVs. Great reviews, I’ll be picking these up asap ­čÖé

    Sunny @ Blue Sky Bookshelf

    1. Lucy says:

      Oh, I’m really interested in hearing what you think of these, Sunny! I like alternating POV’s too. It helps me connect with the characters better.

  4. BermudaOnion says:

    Both of these books sound fun to me and i love the name Gray!

    1. Lucy says:

      The name really suits him!

  5. They sound like really good books- will have to look for them-thanks!

  6. I hadn’t heard of this series at all, Lucy! Knowing you enjoy it so much makes my ears perk up, though, it sounds intriguing. Alternating POVs can be great when they’re done well.

    Wendy @ The Midnight Garden

  7. […] First Comes Love and Second Chance by Katie Kacvinsky […]

Leave a Reply

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.