Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick Audiobook Review

slp movie editionBook: Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick, Blackstone Audio, 2008

Book Info: Audible Purchase. Running time: 7 hrs, 22 mins. Read by: Ray Porter.

Rating: 4 / 5 Stars

Listening to Matthew Quick’s The Good Luck of Right Now recently made me want to listen to the Silver Linings Playbook audiobook. I am already a big fan of the film, but thought it was time I circle back with the source material. And whoa, I never knew the book was so completely different. Reading Quick’s book gave me additional insight into the characters, and basically a completely new story. I can’t help feeling that if you love the book and then see the movie you will be disappointed because the tone is so different, but I still think both are successful in their own way. SLP features Quick’s signature quirky style and lovable misfit characters.  Now that I’ve read three of his five books I’m on a mission to complete my Quick syllabus.

I’m sure you are all familiar with the book or the movie, so I won’t bore you with a long synopsis. SLP is about Pat Peoples, a man looking for his own happy ending after some troubled times. He’s finally home after spending a few years in a mental health facility for some apart time, and life has moved on without him. He wants his estranged wife Nikki back, but meanwhile is on a self-improvement mission to make himself worthy of her. He wants to impress his English teacher wife by reading the classic books she teaches, but is frustrated by their sad endings:

slp throwing book

SLP book vs. movie:

  • Pat Solitano is Pat Peoples in the book
  • The Pat-Tiffany relationship is more friendly than romantic in the book. Also, book Tiffany is a little older than Pat (Jennifer Lawrence is 23 vs. Bradley Cooper’s 39)
  • The dance performance is not really a competition in the book.
  • Pat spends years in the mental health facility (the bad place) in the book, vs. 8 months in the movie
  • Pat does not remember what he did to land in the mental health facility in the book until the end, while movie Pat is very aware.
  • Pat’s relationship with his father is much warmer in the movie.
  • Pat’s trigger song in the book is Kenny G’s Songbird, while it’s Stevie Wonder’s My Cherie Amour in the movie (fun fact: Quick wanted My Cherie Amour as the song in the book but couldn’t land the rights)

Returning to the book, my heart went out to Pat who is trying so hard to be worthy of his wife. As the reader you want Pat to move on, but he is so determined to better himself through his obsessive workouts and reading lists. His workout regimen is pretty inspiring actually. Football is also a big part of the story, and Pat gets reacquainted with friends old and new through tailgate parties and watching the Eagles play.

silver linings playbook eagles game

Quick does a great job of illustrating Pat’s troubled mind and showing his coping strategies. Some of his episodes are hard to swallow, but the humor mixed in keep the tone light. There is a hopeful quality to Quick’s books, such as Pat hoping to find that silver lining in the clouds. I do enjoy Quick’s take on mental illness and the respectful way he portrays his characters. And after reading the book, I’m even more impressed with Bradley Cooper’s portrayal of Pat.

I enjoyed watching the friendships and family relationships evolve over the course of the book. Pat and Tiffany in particular have a unique friendship where they seem to be the only ones who understand what the other is going through. Their relationship is interesting to follow and it’s great to see such a satisfying non-romantic relationship develop.

pat and tiffany slp

Ray Porter performs the audiobook and this is my first experience with his narration. I have listened to three of Quick’s book though, and his writing translates very well to audio in general. Similar to Bradley Cooper’s interpretation of Pat, Porter’s voice is sincere and hopeful. Porter uses different voices and accents for the characters but doesn’t overdo it, and he makes the audiobook even more entertaining. The 7-hour audiobook flew by. Take a listen:

If you liked the movie Silver Linings Playbook, I think you’ll be really interested to check out the book it’s based on. Did you read the book before seeing the movie? What did you think of the adaptation?


8 thoughts on “Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick Audiobook Review

  1. So, flying back from the US last year, I tried to watch this on the plane but then I accidentally snapped my headphones and most people were asleep so I didn’t want to bother calling for new ones. So I watched some of it without sound but gave up!

    I really think I should listen to this audio, it sounds good and the differences between each version are interesting. I’m looking forward to your next two Quick reviews once you’ve read them 😉

  2. BermudaOnion says:

    I adored the movie (I saw it in the theater twice) so I really want to read the book. I just might grab the audio.

  3. I am just starting to get into audio and this sounds like one I should add to my queue. I still need to see the movie, too!

  4. stacybuckeye says:

    I liked the movie and didn’trealize the book was so different. It doesn’t surprise me that they had to romanticize Pat & Tiffany for the film.

  5. fishgirl182 says:

    Great review. I have not read any of Quick’s book but I did enjoy the movie. Interesting fact about the song in the movie/book. I work in music licensing so it’s always interesting to hear these things. I don’t work with the Stevie Wonder catalog but I can imagine that it would have been hard to clear. Perhaps after the success of the book and the great cast for the movie they were more inclined to license it for the film. Now you’ve made me want to watch this movie again.

  6. Cate T. says:

    I preferred the book over the movie. I wasn’t a fan of the casting. I might audiobook this when I decide to revisit the story. 🙂

  7. I love Ray Porter. I am going to give the book a whirl but the movie I just couldn’t get in to 🙁

  8. Amy Sachs says:

    I’ve always wondered whether or not I should read the book since I love the movie so much, but I don’t usually go backwards once I’ve seen the movie version. Maybe this time I will!

Leave a Reply

(Enter your URL then click here to include a link to one of your blog posts.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.